Why Does Automation Sometimes Create More Human Work?
AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

🔍 Read the full analysis: Why Does Automation Sometimes Create More Human Work? on ThorstenMeyerAI.com

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get smart everyday buys delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

TL;DR

A ThorstenMeyerAI.com article published Nov. 20 examines how ATMs automated cash handling without immediately eliminating bank teller jobs. Drawing on economist James Bessen’s research, it says lower staffing needs per branch were offset by branch growth, while later mobile banking helped drive a decline in teller employment.

A Nov. 20 report from ThorstenMeyerAI.com examines why the spread of automated teller machines did not immediately erase bank teller jobs: ATMs reduced the number of tellers needed at each branch, but lower operating costs helped banks open more branches. Citing economist James Bessen’s research, the article describes an early period when employment held up even as cash handling moved to machines, followed later by a decline as customers shifted to phone-based banking.

The report says the number of ATMs in the United States rose from about 100,000 in 1995 to 400,000 in 2010, based on Bank for International Settlements figures used by Bessen. Yet US teller employment rose modestly over a longer period: from about 500,000 in 1980 to 550,000 in 2010, according to Bessen’s figures as summarized by MIT economist David Autor. The periods differ, so the figures do not show that teller employment rose specifically during the ATM increase.

Bessen’s explanation is that branches needed fewer tellers but became cheaper to operate. The article says a typical urban branch’s teller staffing fell from about 20 to 13 between 1988 and 2004, while the number of bank branches in US cities grew by 43% over those years. The report also cites a nationwide FDIC count of commercial bank offices, including head offices and branches, rising from 58,937 in 1988 to 77,302 in 2004.

The work itself shifted as machines took on cash handling. The report says tellers increasingly focused on customer interaction and sales, such as discussing loans, credit cards and investment products. It then describes a later change driven by mobile banking: in 2023, 48.3% of US households with a bank account mainly used mobile banking, compared with 15.1% who mainly used a teller. The article cites US teller employment falling from about 600,500 in 2008 to 339,200 in 2025, attributing those figures to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

At a glance
reportWhen: Published Nov. 20, 2026; the employment…
The developmentA Nov. 20, 2026, report revisits economist James Bessen’s findings that ATMs initially changed teller work and helped banks operate more branches, rather than simply eliminating the occupation.
Thorsten Meyer AI
Work After Work · Ep. 18

Infographic 01 · The paradox

Four times the machines, more tellers

ATMs took over the teller's core task. For three decades, banks answered with more branches, not fewer tellers.

×4ATMs in the US, about 100,000 (1995) to 400,000 (2010)
≈ +10%US bank tellers, about 500,000 (1980) to 550,000 (2010)
20 → 13tellers per branch in a typical US city, 1988 to 2004
+43%bank branches in US cities, 1988 to 2004

US commercial bank offices (head offices + branches) · year-end · FDIC

  • 198052,879
  • 198858,937
  • 1995ATMs start to spread fast65,578
  • 200477,302
  • 2012peak88,522
  • 202572,658

Teller and ATM figures: Bessen’s analysis of Census and American Community Survey microdata, as summarised by Autor (2015); ATM counts from the Bank for International Settlements. Branch growth in cities: Bessen (2015), urban markets. FDIC series: FDIC-insured commercial banks in the US states and DC; savings institutions are not included.

Sources: D. Autor, Journal of Economic Perspectives 29(3), 2015; J. Bessen, Toil and Technology, IMF Finance & Development (March 2015); FDIC, Historical Bank Data (commercial banks, year-end).
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI

How Lower Branch Costs Sustained Jobs

The account matters because it distinguishes the automation of tasks from the disappearance of an entire job. An ATM can handle routine cash withdrawals while leaving other work—answering questions, advising customers and selling financial products—to staff. If automating one task makes a service cheaper to provide, a bank may expand its service footprint, potentially creating demand for workers in the remaining tasks.

That outcome is not a guarantee for workers. The report’s later figures show teller employment falling as mobile banking became more common and branch networks contracted. The history therefore suggests that automation’s effects depend on what happens to customer demand, business costs and the tasks left to people. A job can persist in a changed form for years before another technology or business shift reduces demand for it.

Products Worth Considering

Canon SELPHY CP1500 Compact Photo Printer Kit with 2x KP-108IN Ink and Paper Sets

Canon SELPHY CP1500 Compact Photo Printer Kit with 2x KP-108IN Ink and Paper Sets

Apple MacBook Air 15-inch Laptop with M5 Chip, 16GB Memory, 512GB SSD, Midnight

Apple MacBook Air 15-inch Laptop with M5 Chip, 16GB Memory, 512GB SSD, Midnight

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

From Cash Machines to Mobile Banking

The article traces the first widely noted episode to June 27, 1967, when actor Reg Varney used a Barclays cash machine outside a branch in Enfield, north London. The early machine did not use a plastic card: customers inserted a special cheque marked with carbon-14 and entered a personal code. A German cash machine opened in Tübingen in May 1968, followed by a Docutel cash dispenser installed by Chemical Bank in New York in September 1969, according to the Smithsonian and Computer History Museum, as cited in the report.

For customers, machines made it possible to withdraw cash outside bank opening hours. For banks, they took over some routine counter work. The report says that the initial effect was not a simple, immediate job replacement: staffing per branch fell while branch numbers grew. It presents phone-based banking as a later phase, with US household use of mobile banking and the teller employment figures providing evidence of a different direction.

The report also points to Germany’s shrinking branch network: it fell from 45,467 branches at the end of 2004 to 16,799 at the end of 2025. It says cash machines are now retreating in Germany, China and Japan, but does not give figures for those machine declines.

What the Employment Figures Cannot Show

The figures establish different trends over specified periods, but they do not by themselves prove that ATMs caused branch growth or explain how much each technology contributed to changes in employment. The teller totals cited for 1980–2010, 2008–2025 and the ATM count for 1995–2010 cover different time windows and may use different measurement methods. The article notes that Bessen also calculated full-time-equivalent teller employment from Census and American Community Survey data, but readers should not treat that measure as interchangeable with every employment count cited.

The source does not quantify how many jobs were created or lost because of branch expansion, mobile banking or other changes in banking. Nor does it provide comparable figures for the recent retreat of cash machines in Germany, China and Japan. The causes and scale of those developments remain unclear from the material presented.

The Next Phase of Bank Automation

The article’s account ends with banks and customers moving further away from routine in-person cash services, but it gives no forecast, new study or announced policy milestone. The next evidence to watch is whether future employment and branch data show continued declines alongside reduced use of tellers and cash machines, or whether banks create other customer-facing work.

For now, the report’s central comparison is historical: ATMs expanded rapidly while US teller employment held up over a longer period, then teller employment fell as phone-based banking grew. Those figures do not establish what will happen next. Later data will be needed to distinguish the effects of automation from changes in banking demand, branch strategy and other factors.

Key Questions

Why did ATMs not immediately eliminate bank teller jobs?

According to the report’s account of James Bessen’s research, ATMs reduced staffing needs at each branch, while lower operating costs helped banks open more branches. The remaining teller work also shifted toward customer service and sales.

How much did US teller employment change from 1980 to 2010?

The report cites an increase from about 500,000 in 1980 to 550,000 in 2010, based on Bessen’s figures as summarized by David Autor. This is a comparison across that 30-year period, not a measure of the effect of ATMs alone.

When did US teller employment begin to fall in the figures cited?

The article cites Bureau of Labor Statistics figures showing teller jobs falling from about 600,500 in 2008 to 339,200 in 2025. It links the later period to the growth of phone-based banking but does not isolate mobile banking as the sole cause.

Did ATMs change what bank tellers did?

Yes. The report says machines took over routine cash handling, while tellers moved toward customer interaction and relationship banking, including discussing loans, credit cards and investment products.

Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com

This content is for general information only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Consult a qualified professional for decisions about your money.
You May Also Like

B2Gold Reports Q2 2026 Results; Strong Operating Performance At The Fekola, Masbate, And Otjikoto Mines Led To Higher Than Expected Gold Production And Lower Than Expected All-In Sustaining Costs; Menankoto Exploitation Permit Expected To Be Issued In The Near-Term By The State Of Mali

B2Gold announces Q2 2026 financial results, highlighting strong performance at Fekola and Masbate mines, with higher gold production and lower costs.

ESMA Calls For Changes To Make MiCA Clearer, Safer And Ready For Emerging Services

ESMA has urged the European Commission to clarify MiCA, tighten investor safeguards and supervision, and account for services such as DeFi and staking.

Modal Triples Valuation To $15 Billion As AI Infrastructure Demand Explodes

AI infrastructure startup Modal says it raised $750 million in a Series D at a $15.75 billion valuation, more than triple its May valuation.

707 Cayman Holdings Effects A Share Consolidation On July 14, 2026

707 Cayman Holdings will execute a share consolidation on July 14, 2026, affecting its outstanding shares. The move aims to optimize its capital structure.